Luke 9: 51-62
Roger Lynn
August 25, 2019
I confess that this passage from Luke’s Gospel has often troubled me over the years. It always seemed too harsh. Why would Jesus be so hard on people for wanting to grieve and love their families? Isn’t that what being truly and genuinely human is all about?
And then, as so often happens, as I sought to find a different way to understand this passage, two things came into focus which cast the whole thing in a fresh new light. The first of these insights is one which applies to a wide variety of scriptural references. It has to do with the concept of prescriptive versus descriptive. For a variety of reasons, the most common way of seeking to understand any particular passage is to read it prescriptively. Put simply, we take it to mean that whatever is being described is the way God wants it to be, or even the way God causes it to be. Sometimes we do this because it is how we have been trained to interpret scripture. And sometimes we do this because it is the filter the writers themselves used to interpret the concepts and events they were writing about. In either case, there are a great many instances when reading the Bible prescriptively leaves us with an understanding of God that can be frightening, disturbing, and profoundly unhelpful. Today’s passage is a good example. One of the reasons I have always had such a difficult time with it over the years is because I was trying to read it prescriptively. Thus the question – why would Jesus be so hard on people?
But what if it isn’t Jesus who is being hard on people? What if Jesus is merely describing the way things are when we make certain choices? In other words, what if we read such passages descriptively rather than prescriptively? It changes everything. Some of the language may still prove to be a challenge, but that is because at the time scripture was being written, the prescriptive filter was often the only one available. For the most part, they had not yet recognized the possibility of looking at things any other way. When we begin to look past some of the language to the meaning which can be found underneath, suddenly the comment about not being fit for the kingdom of God becomes a description rather than a judgment. It is as if Jesus is saying, “As long as you are distracted and paying attention to other things, your heart just isn’t in it.”